Skip to content

Woman Accused Of Killing Lover, Dumping Severed Head In Bucket, Just Got Some Bad News From The Judge

A woman who allegedly killed her lover and then chopped his head off and left it in a bucket has officially been deemed competent to stand trial, according to the judge presiding over the case.

In other words, the judge thinks she’s evil to the core, but not crazy. Which means she could be looking at some very serious punishments coming about as a result of her actions, all of which are very much deserved.

Taylor Schabusiness, 24, was found to be mentally fit by a psychological evaluator after she allegedly committed this gruesome crime. She’s currently facing “charges of first-degree intentional homicide, mutilating a corpse, and third-degree sexual assault,” according to Law & Crime.

Quinn Jolly, Schabusiness’ lawyer, stated during a press briefing held on Wednesday that his client “would be seeking a second examination.”

Um, well, if she’s competent enough to know that there’s bad things in store for her if she’s found to be sane, then doesn’t that point to the fact that she’s probably not nuts? Maybe I’m just dumb about this sort of thing.

“The court must appoint one examiner but can appoint more. After review of the report and the examiner’s comments to the court, the court should remain sensitive in the event of any signs of fluctuations in her overall mental status and behavioral stability, such changes may signal fluctuation in her capacity,” he continued.

Here are more details from The Daily Wire:

Law & Crime previously reported that Jolly said Schabusiness had been receiving mental health treatment since the 7th grade and that she had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder.

Brown County District Attorney Dave Lasee said he didn’t feel strongly about whether a second evaluation was needed or not.

“I would note, Dr. Collins is highly respected, and she’s the head of that particular unit and does a number of these, very experienced and does a number of these evaluations,” Lasee went on to say in court. “We’ve accepted her reports on countless occasions. I’m not sure that the county or state should pay for a second evaluation. I know there are other alternatives. The defense is entitled to have an expert evaluate their client at any time under the statute, so I won’t take a strong position one way or the other. I just wanted to note that we highly respect Dr. Collins’s opinions on this issues.”

The Daily Wire previously reported that police in Green Bay, Wisconsin, said they responded to a call from a mother who said she found her son’s head in a bucket in their basement. When they arrived at the home, police found the head in a bucket with a towel on it, along with dried blood on a nearby mattress. The mother told police that her son and Schabusiness had been in the basement earlier that day while the mother and her boyfriend were out of the house. The mother further told police she woke up around 2:30 a.m. to 3:00 a.m. on Wednesday morning after she heard a storm door slamming. She assumed Schabusiness left. She then went down into the basement, where she found her son’s severed head in a bucket.

Schabusiness allegedly talked with police, telling them that she went “crazy” while having sex with the victim, who she stated had wrapped a chain around his neck as part of their, uh, hanky panky session. The woman then claimed that she didn’t mean to kill him, but was enjoying choking him and just kept right on doing it until the poor guy was dead.

Here’s what the police complaint said:

Schabusiness stated she then began to choke the Victim, and she described it as the Victim lying face down on the bed with her on top of him pulling on the end of the chain. The Victim coughed up blood and she was just waiting for him to die while she was watching his face. Schabusiness made the comment that she was “already this far” so she just kept on, referring to choking the Victim. Schabusiness said in a lower tone of voice, “Ya I liked it,” and Detective Graf believed her to be referring to when she was choking the Victim. Schabusiness stated she thought it took 3-5 minutes for the Victim to die. Detective Kempf clarified with Schabusiness that when the Victim began to cough up blood she just did keep on choking the Victim because she wanted to see what happens. Schabusiness made comments that she blacked out while choking the Victim but when she woke up that the Victim was already purple, so she kept on going. Schabusiness stated she enjoyed choking him and made comments to detectives asking if they knew what it was like to love something so much that you kill it.

The woman then reportedly told local law enforcement that she engaged in sexual activity with the victim’s dead body for two to three hours before she dismembered him with a bread knife.

A bread knife, ladies and gentlemen.

“Schabusiness responded that the police were going to have fun trying to find all of the organs,” prosecutors wrote, according to a report from Law & Crime. “Schabusiness stated all of the body parts should be in the basement. Schabusiness stated there should be a foot or a leg in the minivan. Detective Graf asked Schabusiness what she did with the head, and Schabusiness stated she had put the Victim’s head in a black bucket and put a blanket over it.”

“Schabusiness allegedly told police that the knives she used to dismember the victim’s body would be in a black bag in the basement along with the man’s body parts,” the Daily Wire said.

“Schabusiness indicated that she would use whatever bags she found in the basement to place the body parts into. Schabusiness made the comment that at one point, she did get paranoid and lazy and that she thought it was the ‘dope that was making her paranoid,” prosecutors went on to write.

Schabusiness then said that she was planning to take all of the body parts with her, but then got “lazy” and only managed to snag a “leg/foot,” and forgot his head.


This story syndicated with permission from Chad Prather